What strikes any reader of Whitman first is the sheer volume of each poetic line, on the order of a sprawling architecture: call it Empire State or Sears Tower, or even the Mall of America. It is the form of an obese, hyperactive, endlessly (and perhaps vainly) seeking culture.
This, perhaps, is why we prefer Whitman.
The Dinner Guest
Why does Whitman always get new breath,
not Holmes or Whittier, never mind
William Cullen Bryant? How jealous he must be,
the poet who says he stands somewhere waiting
but at the wrong moment or in the wrong meter. How many
tables has Walt graced, invisible perfect guest
who doesn’t trouble you for a napkin
but wipes the spittle of words and wine off
on his own sleeve, his mess of crumbs
its own thank you note sent
and gratefully read?